'Ad limina Apostolorum': Bishops' Conference of U.S.A. - 10

All Church governance must foster communion and mission

On Saturday, 11 September, the Holy Father met at Cas­tel Gandolfo with members of the Bishops' Conference of the United States of America coming from the Ecclesiasti­cal Region of Pennsylvania and New Jersey on the occa­sion of their ad limina visit to Rome.

Speaking of the relationship between the ministerial priesthood and the common priesthood of the baptized, the Pope reminded the Bishops that "a commitment to creating better structures of participation, consultation and shared responsibility should not be misunderstood as a conces­sion to a secular 'democratic' model of governance, but as an intrinsic requirement of the exercise of episcopal au­thority and a necessary means of strengthening that au­thority".

Regarding the events that have recently shaken the Catholic Church in the United States, the Pope said that "the painful period of self-examination provoked by the events of the past two years will bear spiritual fruit only if it leads the whole Catholic community in America to a deeper understanding of the Church's authentic nature and mission".

The following is the Pope's Address to the U.S. Bishops.


Dear Brother Bishops,

1. With fraternal affection I welcome you, the Bishops of the Ecclesiastical Region of Pennsylvania and New Jer­sey, on the occasion of your quinquen­nial visit to the tombs of Sts Peter and Paul. During our ad limina meetings this year I have invited you and your Brother Bishops from the United States to reflect with me on the significance of the ministry entrusted to us as "true and authentic teachers of the faith, pontiffs and pastors" (Christus Dominus, n. 2). Today our considerations turn to the munus regendi, the power of gover­nance by which the successors of the Apostles have been set apart by the Holy Spirit as guardians of the flock and shepherds of the Church of God (cf. Acts 20:28). As the Church's con­stant Tradition attests, this apostolic au­thority is a form of service to the Body of Christ. As such, it can only be in­spired by and modelled on the self-sacri­ficing love of the Lord who came among us as a servant (cf. Mk 10:45) and, after stooping to wash the feet of his disciples, commanded them to do as he had done (cf. Jn 13:15).
The existence of an unequivocal right and duty of governance entrusted to the successors of the Apostles is an essen­tial part of the Church's divinely-willed constitution (cf. Lumen Gentium, n. 18). As a ministerial power, given for building up the Body (cf. II Cor 10:8), this sacra potestas must be seen as one of the hierarchical gifts (cf. Lumen Gen­tium, n. 4) bestowed upon the Church by her divine Founder, and thus a con­stitutive element of that sacred Tradi­tion which contains everything passed down from the Apostles as a means of preserving and fostering the holiness and faith of the People of God (cf. Dei Verbum, n. 8). History amply demon­strates that the firm and sage exercise of this apostolic authority, particularly in moments of crisis, has enabled the Church to preserve her integrity, independence and fidelity to the Gospel in the face of threats from within and without.

A Bishop is above all a witness, teacher, model of holiness

2. Building on the rich reflection on the episcopal munus regendi occasioned by the Council, and in light of the challenges of the new evangelization, the re­cent Synod of Bishops in­sisted on the urgent need to recover a fuller and more authentically "apostolic" un­derstanding of the episcopal office. The Bishop is above all a witness, a teacher and model of holiness, as well as a prudent administrator of the Church's goods. The sacred power which he le­gitimately exercises should be rooted in the moral au­thority of a life completely shaped by his sacramental sharing in Christ's consecra­tion and mission. Indeed, "all that the Bishop says and does must reveal the authority of Christ's word and his way of acting" (Pastores Gregis, n. 43). As a result, "a renewed appreciation of the Bishop's authority will not be expressed by exter­nal signs, but by an ever deeper under­standing of the theological, spiritual and moral significance of this ministry, founded on the charism of apostolicity" (ibid.). Bishops need to be esteemed as successors of the Apostles not only in authority and sacred power, but above all by their apos­tolic life and wit­ness.

In our meet­ings, many of you have expressed your concern about the crisis of confidence in the Church's leader­ship provoked by the recent sexual ­abuse scandals, the general call for accountability in the Church's governance on ev­ery level and the relations between Bishops, clergy and the lay faith­ful. I am con­vinced that today as at every critical moment in her histo­ry, the Church will find the resources for an authentic self-renewal in the wis­dom, vision and zeal of Bishops out­standing for their holiness. Saintly re­formers like Gregory the Great, Charles Borromeo and Pius X understood that the Church is only authentically "re­formed" when she returns to her origins in a conscious reappropriation of the apostolic Tradition and a purifying re-­evaluation of her institutions in the light of the Gospel. In the present circum­stances of the Church in America, this will entail a spiritual discernment and critique of certain styles of governance which, even in the name of a legitimate concern for good "administration" and responsible oversight, can run the risk of distancing the pastor from the mem­bers of his flock, and obscuring his im­age as their father and brother in Christ.

Understanding of ministerial and common priesthood: collaboration

3. In this regard, the Synod of Bishops acknowledged the need today for each Bishop to de­velop "a pastoral style which is ever more open to col­laboration with all" (Pastores Gregis, n. 44), grounded in a clear understand­ing of the relation­ship between the ministerial priest­hood and the common priest­hood of the bap­tized (cf. Lumen Gentium, n. 10). While the Bishop himself remains responsible for the authoritative deci­sions which he is called to make in the exercise of his pastoral governance, ec­clesial communion also "presupposes the participation of every category of the faithful, inasmuch as they share re­sponsibility for the good of the particu­lar Church which they themselves form" (Pastores Gregis, loc. cit.). Within a sound ecclesiology of communion, a commitment to creating better struc­tures of participation, consultation and shared responsibility should not be mis­understood as a concession to a secular "democratic" model of governance, but as an intrinsic requirement of the exer­cise of episcopal authority and a neces­sary means of strengthening that au­thority.

Purification, deeper appreciation of the Church's nature

4. The exercise of the munus regendi is directed both to gathering the flock in the visible unity of a single profession of faith lived in the sacramental commu­nion of the Church and to guiding that flock, in the diversity of its gifts and callings, towards a common goal: the proclamation of the Gospel to the ends of the earth. Every act of ecclesiastical governance, consequently, must be aimed at fostering communion and mission. In view, then, of their com­mon purpose and aim, the three munera of teaching, sanctifying and rul­ing are clearlyg:
inseparable and inter­penetrating: "when the Bishop teaches, he also sanctifies and governs the Peo­ple of God; when he sanctifies, he also teaches and governs; when he governs, he teaches and sanctifies" (Pastores Gregis, n. 9; cf. Lumen Gentium, nn. 20, 27).

Experience shows that when priority is mainly given to outward stability, the impetus to personal conversion, eccle­sial renewal and missionary zeal can be lost and a false sense of security can en­sue. The painful period of self-examina­tion provoked by the events of the past two years will bear spiritual fruit only if it leads the whole Catholic community in America to a deeper understanding of the Church's authentic nature and mission, and a more intense commit­ment to making the Church in your Country reflect, in every aspect of her life, the light of Christ's grace and truth. Here I can only state once more my profound conviction that the Documents of the Second Vatican Council need to be carefully studied and taken to heart by all the faithful, since these normative texts of the Magisterium offer the basis for a genuine ecclesial renewal in obedi­ence to the will of Christ and in conformity with the Church's apostolic Tradition (cf. Novo Millennia Ine­unte, n. 57).

Your 'demanding ministry' is a source of immense spiritual joy

5. Dear Brothers, as you guide the Churches entrust­ed to your pastoral care, may you daily find consola­tion, support and strength from the clergy, Religious and lay faithful whom you serve. The ministry to which you have been called is demanding and even bur­densome, yet it is also a source of immense spiritual joy and an indispensable service to the growth of Christ's disciples in faith, hope and love. With great affection I commend all of you to the prayers of Mary, Mother of the Church, and cordially impart my Apos­tolic Blessing as a pledge of joy and peace in the Lord.

L'Osservatore Romano September 15, 2004
Reprinted with permission